In this article6 sections
S&P Global Ratings has kept Tether’s USDT at a score of 5, the weakest level on its five-point stablecoin stability scale, in an assessment dated Nov. 18. The agency said higher-risk holdings had grown to roughly 28% of USDT in circulation as of Sept. 30, up from 24% a year earlier, and warned that a sharp decline in those assets could leave the token undercollateralized in a severe downturn, Bitcoin.com News reported.
The score is unchanged from November 2025, when S&P cut USDT from 4 (“constrained”) to 5. USDT was worth about $184 billion at the end of September and remains the largest stablecoin by market value.
Also read: Tether posts $1.5B Q3 profit as reserves rebuild to $7.95B
Key facts
- S&P assigned USDT a score of 5 (“weak”) in its Nov. 18 assessment, the same level as in November 2025.
- Higher-risk assets were about 28% of USDT in circulation as of Sept. 30, versus 24% a year earlier.
- Gold holdings rose to about $19 billion from $12.9 billion, publicly traded equities were added at $4.2 billion, and Bitcoin holdings fell to about $8.4 billion from $9.9 billion.
- Tether reported $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities at Sept. 30, an excess cushion of roughly $8 billion and a collateralization ratio of about 104.3%.
- Tether rejected the assessment, telling Cointelegraph that “the problem is S&P’s framework, not our reserves,” according to crypto.news.
Reserve mix shifted toward gold and equities
S&P’s main concern is what backs USDT beyond its short-term U.S. Treasury holdings. The agency placed gold, publicly traded stocks, corporate bonds, secured loans and similar instruments in the higher-risk bucket, and noted that the value of those assets now substantially exceeds the reserve surplus.
crypto.news reported that Tether’s latest figures, attested by BDO Italia, showed $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities, with $132.4 billion in direct and indirect exposure to U.S. Treasury bills. The outlet also reported that the excess buffer nearly doubled from $4.11 billion at the end of June to $7.95 billion at the end of September. S&P cited $8 billion for the same cushion, a rounding difference between the two accounts.
Audit completed, disclosure still limited
Tether completed its first full independent financial statement audit, with KPMG U.S. issuing an unqualified opinion on its 2025 accounts; crypto.news reported the announcement was made in August and that KPMG physically inspected and counted Tether’s gold bars. S&P said the statements, notes and auditor’s report were not made public, limiting outside scrutiny of credit quality, custodians and counterparties.
Crypto Briefing reported a further strand of the critique: S&P questioned legal protections for reserves after Tether’s 2025 move from the British Virgin Islands to El Salvador, whose rules the agency considers looser than European and U.S. standards because they allow Bitcoin, gold and loans without requiring segregation. Crypto Briefing also noted the agency’s earlier concern that Bitcoin’s share of reserves, at about 5.6% of USDT in circulation, exceeded the 3.9% overcollateralization buffer; S&P’s November 2026 assessment instead centers on the 28% higher-risk figure.
Redemption limits and chain concentration
Access to direct redemption remains restricted to verified customers holding at least $100,000 in tokens, with a $150 verification charge and a redemption fee of $1,000 or 0.1%, whichever is higher, crypto.news reported. Tron held 50.7% of circulating USDT as of Oct. 25, Ethereum 46.8% and Solana 1.6%. S&P still credited USDT with a strong record of holding its peg over the preceding 12 months.
Why it matters
USDT is the deepest pool of dollar liquidity in crypto, so its reserve quality feeds into trading, lending and settlement well beyond Tether’s own balance sheet. S&P’s comparison with Circle’s USDC, which it rates “strong,” gives institutional holders a second data point when they weigh which dollar token to accept. The main substance of the critique would weaken if Tether trimmed higher-risk assets or published fuller reserve disclosures.
What to watch
Tether’s next quarterly reserve attestation, and whether the audited 2025 statements or KPMG’s opinion are released publicly, will show whether the reserve mix or the disclosure gap moves. The higher-risk share and the size of the excess cushion are the figures S&P said would drive any change in the score.
Reported by Bitcoin.com News.
Sources: Bitcoin.com News, crypto.news, Crypto Briefing

