Japan Crypto ETF: SBI CEO Slams 2028 Timeline as ‘Too Late’ in Urgent Warning

Tokyo, Japan – May 2025: The CEO of one of Japan’s largest financial institutions has issued a stark warning about the nation’s pace of financial innovation. Asakura Tomoya, CEO of SBI Global Asset Management, has publicly criticized a reported government plan to approve spot cryptocurrency Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) by 2028, labeling the timeline “too late” and a risk to Japan’s competitive standing. His comments, made on social media platform X, respond directly to a Nikkei Shimbun report outlining the Financial Services Agency’s (FSA) expected regulatory roadmap. Asakura argues that a four-year wait places Japan dangerously behind global leaders like the United States and emerging rivals in Asia, potentially ceding significant ground in the rapidly evolving digital asset ecosystem.

Japan Crypto ETF Delay Sparks Industry Backlash

The controversy centers on a fundamental disconnect between regulatory caution and market velocity. According to the Nikkei report, Japan’s FSA is methodically constructing a framework for spot crypto ETFs, with a target launch window around 2028. This timeline includes parallel work on crucial tax reforms for digital assets, aiming to create a holistic regulatory environment. For executives like Asakura Tomoya, however, this deliberate pace is a strategic liability. In his view, the global race for cryptocurrency adoption and investment product innovation is measured in months, not years. The United States approved its first spot Bitcoin ETFs in early 2024, triggering an influx of institutional capital. Hong Kong followed shortly after with its own suite of products. Asakura’s critique underscores a growing fear within Japan’s financial sector: that prolonged hesitation will allow other financial hubs to solidify first-mover advantages, capturing market share, talent, and technological leadership that may be difficult to reclaim later.

Global ETF Landscape and Japan’s Positioning

To understand the urgency in Asakura’s statement, one must examine the accelerating global adoption of crypto ETFs. A spot ETF holds the actual underlying asset—in this case, cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin or Ethereum—providing investors with direct exposure without the complexities of custody and security associated with buying tokens directly. The approval of these products in the U.S. marked a watershed moment, legitimizing crypto as an asset class for mainstream portfolios and attracting billions in assets under management within a year.

• United States: Multiple spot Bitcoin ETFs launched in January 2024. Their success demonstrated massive latent demand from both retail and institutional investors.
• Hong Kong: Approved spot Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs in April 2024, positioning itself as Asia’s leading crypto-friendly financial center.
• Europe & Canada: Have offered various crypto-related exchange-traded products for several years, though with different structures than the U.S. spot model.
• Australia & Brazil: Among other nations that have also approved similar investment vehicles.

This creates a clear competitive map. By 2028, these markets will have enjoyed four more years of product refinement, investor education, and capital formation. Japan, once a fintech pioneer, risks becoming a follower. The concern is not merely about offering an investment product but about the broader ecosystem it supports, including brokerage services, custody solutions, market-making, and financial technology development.

Regulatory Philosophy: Safety vs. Speed

The FSA’s cautious approach is rooted in Japan’s historical experience with financial innovation and its aftermath. The agency is renowned for its stringent investor protection standards, a philosophy solidified after events like the collapse of the Mt. Gox cryptocurrency exchange in 2014, which was based in Tokyo. The FSA’s mandate prioritizes systemic stability and consumer safety, often leading to meticulous, multi-stage review processes for new financial instruments. This method has built immense trust in Japan’s financial system but can conflict with the breakneck speed of technological change in the crypto sector. The proposed 2028 timeline likely reflects the complexity of integrating a volatile, novel asset class into the country’s tightly governed financial markets while ensuring anti-money laundering (AML) compliance, tax clarity, and operational resilience. Asakura’s critique challenges whether this traditional regulatory tempo can adapt to the digital age’s demands.

Economic Implications of a Slow Adoption Timeline

The delay carries tangible economic consequences. Financial innovation is a key driver of economic vitality, attracting foreign investment and fostering high-skilled jobs. A prolonged hold on spot crypto ETFs could lead to capital outflow, as Japanese investors and institutions seek exposure through foreign markets and products. This not only deprives domestic brokers and exchanges of fee revenue but also weakens Japan’s influence in shaping global digital asset standards. Furthermore, the timeline may hinder the growth of Japan’s Web3 and blockchain startup scene, as entrepreneurs and developers might perceive the regulatory environment as unsupportive and opt to launch projects in more agile jurisdictions like Singapore or Dubai. In a global competition for technological leadership, regulatory speed is increasingly a form of economic policy.

The Path Forward: Industry Calls for Accelerated Action

Asakura’s public comments are part of a broader lobbying effort by Japan’s financial industry. The call is not for reckless deregulation but for a more agile and ambitious legislative schedule. Proponents argue that the foundational work—including Japan’s existing Payment Services Act, which recognizes crypto as a form of property—provides a sufficient starting point. They suggest that the FSA could implement a phased rollout, beginning with a tightly controlled pilot program for institutional investors before a full public launch. This would allow regulators to monitor real-world performance and risks without committing to a full four-year delay. The simultaneous work on tax reform is widely acknowledged as critical; Japan’s current tax treatment of crypto profits as “miscellaneous income” is a significant barrier to adoption. Clarifying and rationalizing this tax regime is seen as inseparable from any successful ETF launch.

Conclusion

The debate over Japan’s crypto ETF timeline is a microcosm of a larger challenge facing established economies: how to balance regulatory prudence with the imperative to innovate. Asakura Tomoya’s warning that 2028 is “too late” highlights the real risk of Japan ceding its financial influence in Asia and beyond. While the FSA’s commitment to safety is prudent, the global market for digital assets will not pause. The coming months will reveal whether Japanese policymakers can accelerate their roadmap to keep pace with competitors, or if the nation’s cautious approach will result in a significant, and potentially lasting, strategic setback in the future of finance. The decision will signal Japan’s vision for its role in the next era of global capital markets.

FAQs

Q1: What is a spot cryptocurrency ETF?
A spot cryptocurrency ETF is an exchange-traded fund that holds the actual digital assets, like Bitcoin or Ethereum, in custody. It allows investors to gain exposure to the price movement of the crypto through a traditional brokerage account, without needing to manage private keys or use a crypto exchange directly.

Q2: Why does the SBI CEO think Japan’s 2028 timeline is a problem?
Asakura Tomoya believes the four-year wait will cause Japan to fall irreversibly behind other major financial markets that have already approved such products, like the U.S. and Hong Kong. This could lead to capital flight, loss of industry talent, and a diminished role for Japan in shaping the global digital asset ecosystem.

Q3: What is the Financial Services Agency (FSA) likely considering in its timeline?
The FSA is known for a meticulous, safety-first approach. Its 2028 target likely accounts for the need to develop comprehensive custody rules, finalize tax treatment for crypto assets, ensure robust anti-money laundering controls, and conduct thorough market stability assessments before approving a new, volatile asset class for mass retail investment.

Q4: Has Japan approved any crypto-related investment products yet?
Yes, Japan has approved crypto futures ETFs and ETFs that invest in companies related to blockchain technology. However, it has not yet approved a spot ETF that holds the physical cryptocurrencies, which is the product type causing the current debate and the one available in other markets.

Q5: How does Japan’s current crypto tax system affect ETF adoption?
Japan currently taxes cryptocurrency profits as “miscellaneous income,” which can incur a marginal tax rate above 50%. This is a major disincentive for investors. For a spot crypto ETF to succeed, concurrent tax reforms that treat crypto investment more like other securities are considered essential, which is part of the FSA’s reported 2028 package.

Related News

• Binance Unleashes Exciting MMT Trading Opportunities: Margin Pairs and Perpetual Futures Go Live
• Crypto Market News Today: Analyzing LINK and SHIB Declines as DeepSnitch AI Gains Momentum
• GSR Invests in Maverix Securities to Support the Launch of Regulated Digital Asset Structured Products

Related: Digital Asset Funds Suffer Fourth Week of Outflows as U.S. Investors Pull a Staggering $403M

Related: Metaplanet's Blockbuster FY2025 Overshadowed by Staggering Unrealized Bitcoin Loss

Related: Binance Denies Explosive Fortune Report on Alleged Iran-Linked Crypto Transfers